Death at the Day Lily Cafe - 3 Stars - Forgettable but author has potential

Death at the Day Lily Cafe by Wendy Sand Eckel
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I received an advance reader's copy of this title from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.

Death at the Day Lily Cafe is a cozy mystery set in small town America. The main character is divorcee, Rosalie Hart. Rosalie has inherited her aunt's farm and has started a restaurant serving locally raised, organic produce and locally made pastries. Life is almost idyllic for Rosalie, her daughter Annie, staff at the cafe, including Glenn, Crystal and Custer, and Tyler, who works on the farm and is slowly working his way into Rosalie's heart.

However, this is a mystery series, so someone has murdered local flooring construction owner Carl James, or CJ Fiddler, and the Sheriff believes it was his wife, Lori. Doris, Lori's sister, is desperately looking for someone to help find the real killer because the Sheriff is sure he has his murderer. So, Doris and Lori turn to Rosalie who has previously helped solve a case in the area. Rosalie jumps into the fray, and the Sheriff is not too pleased.

The story is gentle, without much angst or violence and the characters are nice people who work hard and are looking out for each other. The story also has a touch of romance, and a lot of great sounding food from the cafe, with some recipes included at the end of the book. The murder is fairly quickly tied to greed, so we know it is unlikely anyone else is in danger. Rosalie carefully goes from one neighbor to the next questioning what they know about CJ, Lori and the possible motive for the crime. The Sheriff is not a nice person, but he also is working hard and his past is putting him in a vindictive mood.

Another reviewer used the word I would use to describe this story - forgettable. Despite the nice people and the good food and the mystery, the story just isn't that exciting, the dialogue is pretty mundane, and the resolution of the murder comes as a surprise, but without any great excitement or climax. This isn't a bad story. I gave it three stars, which means I liked it. But, I would not go out of my way to read the next or first books in the series. I think, though, this author has potential!


View all my reviews